The characters jumped off the page into Hoblit's consciousness, especially
the scene in which Crawford and Willy first meet. Crawford has confessed to
his wife's murder, and Willy, feeling all the power of his position as an assistant
district attorney, questions Crawford believing his case to be a neat slam dunk. "When
I read that scene, I couldn't wait to shoot it," Hoblit acknowledges. "Everything
else just radiated from the confrontation between them. Being able to shoot
the creative dynamic of that sequence was probably the single most exciting
day I've had in 25 years in this business."
Anthony Hopkins portrays Ted Crawford
Anthony Hopkins portrays Ted Crawford, an engineer and scientist who specializes
in fracture mechanics, analyzing aeronautical malfunctions and plane crashes.
He prides himself on being able to spot even the smallest defect or weakness
in any system,mechanical or otherwise.
It took only one read for Hopkins to sign onto the project. "It's a smart,
sophisticated,well-written script," explains Hopkins. "You don't
get many of those today. Being asked to participate was a stroke of luck."
But do not ask Hopkins about his character's motivations he's quick to
direct you elsewhere for an answer. "I'm not a film scholar, so I never
analyze the ingredients of a good film. I never go into a character's subtext," he
says. "Ask the writer for the reasons why someone does something. I just
let it emerge."
Producer Charles Weinstock laughs at the ease with which Hopkins dismisses
any attempt to psychoanalyze his character. "Tony just plunges right in," he
says, describing his take on Hopkins' acting style.
"This was one of the most enjoyable experiences I've had on a movie in a
long time," says Hopkins. "The part is very wittily written. Crawford
is like Iago, he's got cards hidden up his sleeve. If it's written well, it's
easy to play."
"I've played two criminals in my life," he continues, "Hannibal
Lecter and this guy. He's a control freak. He's fascinated by precision but that's
the very flaw in his nature. He likes to toy with people, he likes walking on
the edge, and he's a little too smart for his own good, which eventually undoes
"People make a big deal about acting," Hopkins says, "but I never
treat it like a mathematical formula. The character is an engineer OK, I'm
a smart criminal; they put me in nice clothes and give me an expensive car to
drive OK, I'm a rich criminal. It's as simple as that."
"The character of Crawford has all kinds of colors," Gregory Hoblit
says. "From being a cold sociopath, to a charmer, to a game player, to being
funny, to being deadly. There aren't many actors who can cover that territory
with ease. Anthony's an interesting guy;he doesn't mind going to that dark center
he has tucked away, and he's able to convey bitterness more elegantly than any
actor I know."
Given that Hopkins only appears in six or seven scenes for a total of about
25 minutes of the film, "the cumulative impact of those scenes is imperative," explains
Hoblit,emphasizing the actor's impact. "His delivery of those scenes is
what makes the movie."
The filmmakers were determined to avoid the pitfalls of the robotic, one-dimensional antagonist. "Ted
Crawford could have been a one-note, heartless bad guy," says Hoblit. "But
Tony being Tony a man with such depth you don't know where it will end,
or even if you want to get to the bottom of what's lurking beneath the surface he's
graced with such intelligence and his gifts are so formidable, you can imagine
Ted Crawford is the type of man who would love to have a normal relationship,
but just can't do it. He's blocked, and so we find Crawford jammed, with a cold,
mechanical look at the world and a need to abuse. Even when he shoots his wife,
as ruthless a moment as that is, you get the feeling that he's conflicted and
confused. He's a sad character."
Producer Charles Weinstock agrees. "Ted is wounded and because he's
so intelligent and complicated, he's been able to dress and hide those wounds."
"He's the classic tragic character," agrees screenwriter Glenn Gers. "He
thinks he can step outside the law and the bounds of decent human behavior, and
for a while he's astonishingly successful at it, but then his crime haunts him
and in the end he's brought low by his own arrogance."
"I'd written a few notes that were very `Hannibal Lecter,'" adds Gers. "But
to his credit,Tony's response was that he'd already done it before and wanted
to make this guy different; Tony brought humanity and grace to this character
which made for more than just a cold, nasty villain."
Ryan Gosling admits that an actor's reaction to any script depends heavily
on their frame of mind at the time they read it. "I was living in a tent
for two months, so when I talked to Greg Hoblit from my tent, it definitely
sounded interesting," he laughs. "But I honestly wasn't sure what
I could bring to the table," he says on a more serious note. "I just
knew it was something I should do. I liked the suspense, I liked that I couldn't
figure it out when I first read it, and I liked that Anthony Hopkins was playing
Crawford. It's not everyday you get to work with one of your heroes."
Hoblit believes the stars were in perfect alignment for destiny to seemingly
guide the casting process as it did. "We cast by dent of some good luck
and persistence," he says. "There is not a single role I would cast
differently had we the chance to do it allover again. " Good fortune for
the filmmakers because every actor felt exactly the same as Hoblit, expressly
mentioning time and again their respect for him and their enthusiasm at being
able to work with the director of Primal Fear.
Hoblit first noticed Gosling when he saw The Believer, which premiered at
the 2001Sundance Film Festival. "What's perfectly clear right off the bat
is that Ryan has an abundant talent," declares Hoblit. "The kind of
focus and intensity he has can't be taught you just have it or you don't.
That, coupled with his off-beat good looks and natural charisma, made it a pretty
"The minute you lay eyes on the character of Willy, you know he's a smart
guy," says Hoblit. "Ryan embodies that. His intelligence is completely
apparent and because he's such a facile actor and has so many gears, I find him
compelling to watch. I honestly can't name another actor in his age range
who's as engrossing. Shooting was endlessly interesting because nothing was ever
the same from take to take because Ryan tries to find the truth in each moment.
I knew he'd be a beautiful foil for Anthony."
Gosling sees his character in a simple light
Gosling sees his character in a simple light. "Willy wiggles like a worm
on Crawford's hook," he says. "He basically tortures Willy, and Willy
gets caught up in something totally out of his control. There's no relationship
between them from Willy's perspective; it's all created by Crawford."
"But Willy can't lose this case because it will jeopardize both of his jobs," continues Gosling. "Either
the job he has or the one he wants to have. So losing is not really an option.
And on a fundamental level, he doesn't want to see a murderer set free,especially
someone who's enjoying outsmarting the law, and him, as much as Crawford seems
"This story is about growing up and growing a soul," says screenwriter
Glenn Gers. "Willy's a little slick at the beginning, but he has no choice
but to mature as he encounters tragedy and real loss. He's a little careless with
other people and he discovers the cost of that carelessness."
"The movie is like a chess game," says Gregory Hoblit. "It's got
moves and counter moves and finally a checkmate. Crawford is the chess master who's
thought out every possible move, from beginning to end, and Willy is like one
of those speed players you see in Central Park, an Energizer bunny up against
this stolid, methodical guy. I liked the striking difference between their physiognomies;
one is grown up, and clearly,the other is not. But Willy goes from being a callow
youth to being a man at the end of the day."
The differences were not only apparent between the characters, but also between
the actors and their approach to the material. The cast and director rehearsed
for two weeks before start of production.
"Tony is extremely precise and economical," describes Hoblit. "There's
no wasted motion anywhere, while Ryan's engine wants to warm up and get going
in order to find itself. He goes from being good to being quite extraordinary
when everything clicks."
Hopkins appreciated the director's economical style of shooting using several
cameras at once to get the most out of every moment, rather than making his
actors shoot take after take, in effect draining the scene of its very essence
and flavor. "Greg is smart and very prepared, which is always best for
the production. But he also has good instincts.We didn't do a lot of takes,
which was a relief," says Hopkins.
Acknowledged for a wicked sense of humor, Hopkins would tease the assembled
crew by barking like a dog and then sit innocently as a production assistant
frantically searched to quiet the errant hound.
"He really does sound like a dog," declares Gosling. "He just
one of those people who's good at everything he paints, he writes music,
he directs and he does great imitations of cats and dogs. He's a lot funnier than
I thought he'd be, just a regular guy."
"You've got to have some fun," Hopkins says mischievously, "otherwise
it's not worth getting out of bed in the morning. "
"Tony is very collaborative," says Charles Weinstock, "and he
doesn't exploit the anxiety that most people feel in his presence. He just isn't
interested in that."
Weinstock reports that Hopkins has the energy and stamina "of a 20-year-old
at four or five in the morning, just roaring to go."
Billy Burke, best known for his role as Firefighter Dennis Gauquin in Ladder
49, plays Detective Rob Nunally, a married man in the midst of a torrid affair
with Crawford's wife,Jennifer.
"Nunally falls in love with the wrong woman at the wrong time," says
screenwriter Glenn Gers. "And the sad thing is, it's real love. They're trying
to find a way out, even if it's going to be difficult, and once Crawford mixes
in, Nunally is just doomed. You really feel for him."
"I knew going in that Nunally was going to be the hardest role to cast," says
Gregory Hoblit. "He's a guy who goes from A to Z. Happy in love, optimistic
and then in despair,and not a whole lot of scenes to get there. The role demanded
a range that was considerable. I also needed to believe he was a cop who could
attract a woman like Jennifer Crawford, who comes from a lofty station in life."
"Billy had the chops to make those transitions," Hoblit continues. "He's
handsome and believable as Jennifer's lover, as someone who had some humanity
along with the physical power, that kind of `don't mess around with me' demeanor."
As luck would have it, Burke had recently completed a project during which
he worked with professional hostage negotiators, so the actor was already up
to speed when it came to his character's profession. For Burke, the challenge
was keeping up to date with his character's moods.
"It's rare in a movie like this, where the audience sees only bits and pieces
of a character, yet that character has an entire arc, so it's a great role, the
kind I usually lose to a bigger name," jokes Burke. "But I was licking
my chops at the thought of getting this movie."
"I don't often find myself coming to work, trying to figure out what's going
on in the story," he explains. "I would work for a few days, be off
for a few, come back and have to get back into the plot which wasn't always easy,
so consistency was everything. Was this guy in a period of revelation? Depressed?
Desperate? Resigned? It was a definite challenge, but it was also fun."
"Billy had the most difficult part," concedes Ryan Gosling, "but
he handled it beautifully.It was a pleasure to work with him."
Anthony Hopkins is concise and enthusiastic in his praise for his co-star,
calling Burke "a wonderful actor" and "one to really watch."
Gregory Hoblit, who has a long and respected history with the police genre
in film and television, understands the chaos of a cop's life on the street
and at home. He is attracted by the dichotomy of that life and by the dangers
they face each day in making life choices.
Although Hoblit was blown away by Burke's initial audition, he wanted to
be sure his performance was not a fluke and asked him to read a second time,
making sure Burke could hit every emotional note of this complex character. "He
was every bit as good, if not better," reports Hoblit. "For me, hiring
Billy was a no-brainer."
"It was the same with Rosalind Pike and Hemet Davidtz," he says of
his two leading ladies. "They were roles that you don't know quite what to
do with. At one point, there were some pretty big names being bandied about. The
role of Jennifer Crawford, for example, is small, but it's a dramatic moment that
no one will forget."
Hoblit had previously worked with Embeth Davidtz on Fallen, starring Denzel Washington,
and was eager to repeat the experience. When he and casting director Deborah
Aquila came up with the idea to call Davidtz at the same time, Hoblit saw it
as another positive omen.
"Embeth has this fragile, butterfly quality to her," he says. "While
she is very strong underneath, she has a delicate demeanor and wonderful, emotional
eyes, never mind the fact that she's very talented. I didn't expect her to say
`yes,' because the role is so small, but her response was immediate. It was gratifying.
Bingo! We couldn't have made a more perfect choice."
One of the most difficult aspects of the film was introducing a woman who is
cheating on her husband, while at the same time, getting the audience to feel
for her and care about the adulterous couple.
"Embeth's quiet grace helped in that regard," says screenwriter Glenn
Gers. "She only has two scenes to become sympathetic and then the audience
needs to care about her for the rest of the story. That's not easy."
"Jennifer Crawford exists in a stone-cold marriage," Hoblit says, defending
Davidtz's character. "She's married to a sociopath, a brilliant but bloodless
guy, who is an emotional abuser who shuts her off and belittles her. But this
is the back story that we only discover as the movie moves forward. There is only
one moment between Jennifer and her husband to convey all the dynamics of their
relationship. The audience has to empathize with her and understand that this
is not a person who is out having trysts in hotel rooms for fun."
"I don't believe for a minute that Jennifer married Ted for money," says
Gers. "She thought he would treat her well and she truly loved his strength.
She wasn't betraying him, she was changing, and he couldn't stand that. This is
not a woman who enjoys her immoral act, she's simply afraid to leave her husband."
"The one scene between Crawford and Jennifer took a while to write," Gers
continues," because we had to make it shorter and shorter, strangely enough.
People who have been together a long time have less to say, but each sentence
has to have more weight,and Tony and Embeth knew exactly what to do with the
"She's very beaten down," says Embeth Davidtz about her character, "but
I loved the fact that Jennifer is trying to make her way back into the world and
takes matters into her own hands in a way."
The actress was delighted to work opposite Hopkins, but the role she thought
would be a walk in the park turned out to have unusual challenges. "Of
course it was challenging to act opposite Anthony Hopkins, trying to match him
line for line," says Davidtz. "Because his delivery is insanely good.
And acting with Billy Burke was great fun I don't know where he's been
hiding all these years. But the real work was lying in bed, pretending to be
in a coma day after day. I thought it was going to be fabulous and easy, but
I found it much harder than I expected."
On the other side of the female spectrum is Nikki Gardner, played by British
actress Rosamund Pike. The polar opposite of Jennifer Crawford, Nikki is intimidated
by no one.
"Nikki is a siren," says Gers. "She tempts Willy. She is
the personification of the job that he has wanted all his life and she seduces
him away from the Crawford case towards a really attractive alternative, but he
has to decide if he can pay the price."
"I don't think Willy has ever met anyone as narcissistic as he is," says
Ryan Gosling about Pike's character. "There's something attractive about
that initially, and they recognize a familiar ambitious quality in one another.
I wouldn't categorize Willy and Nikki as a love story; it's more that they're
challenged by one another. They're both alpha and the struggle to be on top is
what's more interesting than the two people in the relationship."
"Nikki is not used to being disarmed by people," agrees Rosamund Pike. "Willy
is not what she expected. He intrigues her and frustrates her at the same time. "
Rosamund Pike first came to Gregory Hoblit's attention when he saw a trailer
for Pride and Prejudice. The actress happened to be in Los Angeles on a promotional
tour for the film while making rounds at the major studios at the same time.
The filmmakers were thrilled when she was able to find time in her hectic schedule
to meet with them, and as soon as she left the room, Hoblit began a tireless
campaign to convince production executives that although a Brit, Pike was the
perfect choice for the role of the ambitious career woman, Nikki Gardner.
"Rosamund was a find," says producer Charles Weinstock. "She has
that cool blond perfection that Grace Kelly had, which served us well when her
character had to be seductive and aloof. Nikki represents temptation in all its
forms, romantic and professional. She's the carnal expression of Willy's ambition.
But the role was harder than that, because Nikki also warms up, and exposes a
weakness or two. Rosamund did a wonderful job of straddling those two ends of
Surprisingly, Pike found the role somewhat disconcerting. "I actually
found it difficult because Nikki is someone I don't personally agree with ethically,
politically, or even stylistically. She's one of those incredibly driven women
who have chosen a career at the expense of family, relationships, a love life
and anything outside her job, which is admirable in its way, but I can't relate
to her. "
"Nikki goes out on a limb for Willy," Pike continues. "She's let
him get under her skin and goes head to head with her boss for him and humiliates
herself in the process. "
"I did try to humanize her a bit," the actress admits, "to show
a glimmer of the kind of woman she used to be. I went a bit against the script
to try to soften her, but when I did,Greg would ask me to drive the moment forward
and give it more power and I'd think to myself, `well, that's the sympathetic
side gone again,'" she laughs.
Rounding out the cast is David Strathairn as Willy's boss and persistent conscience,District
Attorney Joe Lobruto; New Zealand native Cliff Curtis as Nunally's partner,Detective
Flores; and Bob Gunton as Nikki's father, Judge Gardner.
The filmmakers were surprised but delighted that Strathairn would consider
the supporting role of Joe Lobruto, especially as he accepted the part on the
heels of his2006 Oscar® nomination for Best Actor for his portrayal of
Edward R. Murrow in GoodNight and Good Luck.
In discussions with Hoblit, Strathairn explained that he envisioned Willy Beachum
being tugged in different directions, as though from a series of bungee cords,
each held by people in his life pulling from the other end. Always up for a
challenge, Strathairn thought it would be interesting to be a character manipulating
one of those cords.
"Lobruto is a small part," says Glenn Gers, "but it's a powerful
one. He is the opposite of Nikki and he's pulling Willy in the other direction.
He is Willy's conscience waiting to be found.
"David is one of my favorite actors," says the writer, who was only
too thrilled to watch Strathairn interpret his lines. "It's wonderful to
see him being celebrated at last. He brought a real decency to the part, which
is what Willy needs to see when he's dealing with the consequences of taking the
wrong path. "
"Lobruto likes to think of himself as Willy's mentor," says Strathairn, "not
just as his boss.He's proud he made the choice to be a D.A. and not go for the
big bucks at some huge firm, so there's a flint edge between Willy and him that
motivates Lobruto's behavior. "
"Willy and Lobruto have each other all wrong," says Ryan Gosling. "Willy
thinks Lobruto is a self-righteous public servant and Lobruto thinks Willy is
a sellout, a punk. Their relationship is about figuring out how right or how wrong
each is about the other. "
Strathairn is another of Gosling's acting heroes. "I love David's work," says
Gosling. "It was an honor to work with him. He's very inclusive in terms
of his process, which was great for someone like me. He's a gardener in real
life and that describes exactly how he works; he rolls up his sleeves and really
gets his hands dirty. "
"I've never done a role like this where you're essentially a messenger," says
Strathairn. "There's a lot of exposition brought to bear through the D.A.'s
office about the case,about Willy and his journey. The challenge is in adding
to the mix and not being a boring,utilitarian information center. "
Cliff Curtis portrays Rafael Flores, the detective on duty fated to catch the
Crawford attempted-homicide case. Unfortunately for Willy, the only people Flores
dislikes more than criminals are lawyers. Known for his role in Whale Rider,
Curtis is used to playing a wide variety of ethnicities and nationalities. A
chameleon, Curtis is quickly becoming a master at different regional accents.
His dedication to acting and his curiosity to learn more about his character
enticed the filmmakers to expand the role.
"Cliff is electrifying," says Gregory Hoblit. "His presence and
personality are unusual,and he has this deadpan way about him, but because his
accent is pretty distinct, we had to really work on that. He didn't really have
a frame of reference in terms of being a cop, so he was ferocious about getting
it right. No actor was as intent about the process. "
By all rights, Detective Flores and Willy Beachum should be comrades in arms, strategizing
to put the criminal behind bars, but they soon find themselves in a stalemate,
frustrated at the lack of hard evidence for what should be a clear-cut conviction.
"Flores and Willy are completely different personalities," explains
Ryan Gosling. "They're from different backgrounds with different life perspectives
but they have to work together on this case. They kind of blame each other for
the situation they're in. "
Another small but important role is that of Nikki's father, Judge Gardner.
Hoblit remembered Bob Gunton from his performance as the warden in The Shawshank Redemption
and knew that casting director Deborah Aquila was old friends with the actor. "Bob
is stolid," describes Hoblit. "We needed someone who was credible
and like Jennifer Crawford, memorable. When Deb brought up Bob, it was an easy
Since his days working with Steven Bochco on "Hill Street Blues," Hoblit
has strived for verisimilitude when it comes to telling stories about the law. "I
want to make it right," he says plainly. "I want to get all the cop
stuff right, the courtroom drama, the law. Over the years audiences have become
sophisticated and they know if you are playing fast and loose with them, or
Obviously laws are different in every state, but the filmmakers took great
pains to be authentic in their depiction of the action. Not only is Hoblit experienced
in crime drama,producer Chuck Weinstock is himself a "lapsed attorney" who
worked as a lawyer under Mayor Koch and Mayor Dinkins in New York City. The
filmmakers also relied on the services of attorney Bob Breech, who previously
worked for Hoblit on the popular series, "Hill Street Blues" and "L.A.
Law. " According to Hoblit, Breech has "great story sense. "
"Bob knows the law inside and out," says Hoblit, "and he understands
how to get the best out of a scene dramatically while attending to all the legal
aspects at play. "
"The politics, the etiquette of the courtroom, it's all very complicated," says
Ryan Gosling. "Bob was a big help. "
Technical Advisor Peter Weireter
The filmmakers also took advantage of technical advisor Peter Weireter, a chief hostage negotiator with the Los Angeles Police Department, and his colleague Sgt. Lou Reyes.